Is it illegal to speak Spanish in Montana Is speaking Spanish in Montana a sufficient justification for a border patrol agent to detain American citizens on American soil

Is it illegal to speak Spanish in Montana? Is speaking Spanish in Montana a sufficient justification for a border patrol agent to detain American citizens on American soil?

No, it’s not illegal to speak Spanish in Montana, but evidently it’s justification to be questioned and detained by the Border Patrol to establish citizenship.
According the ACLU in Arizona:
It is illegal for law enforcement officers to perform any stops, searches, detentions, or deportations based on your race, national origin, religion, sex, or ethnicity.
These women were lawfully detained because they were speaking Spanish, which apparently was probable cause.
At the time he detained them he didn’t know know they were American citizens, that’s why he questioned them and then detained to them to establish that.
Question: How do you suggest Border Patrol agents determine whether someone is an illegal alien?

Not according to the Constitution and adjudicated US law.
You can only be detained and required to show ID if there is reasonable suspicion that you have committed a crime.
Those two women were illegally detained and should sue the pants off the CPB.
And we should sue that stupid agent, because that suit will be paid off with taxpayer money.
Do Spanish speaking people find it offensive when a nonnative Spanish speaker tries to speak Spanish with them

  • Do Spanish speaking people find it offensive when a nonnative Spanish speaker tries to speak Spanish with them
  • How does an American speaking Spanish sound to a native Spanish speaker
  • If someone speaks Castillian Spanish from Spain can that person understand Spanish of all other Spanish speaking countries
  • Among Hispanic American dialects of Spanish is Mexican Spanish the nearest to Castilian Spanish
  • Among Hispanic American dialects of Spanish is Mexican Spanish the nearest to Castilian Spanish
  • How can I learn Latin American Spanish Mexican Spanish
  • What do Spanish speakers think of non Spanishspeaking Latinos
  • How do Hispanic people feel when nonnative Spanish speakers speak in Spanish to them
  • How is American Spanish different from other Spanish accents
  • How hard is it for an American to learn Spanish
  • Do any Filipinos speak Spanish
  • Do Brazilians want to speak Spanish
  • Do any Filipinos speak Spanish
  • Do Brazilians want to speak Spanish
  • How do I speak Spanish faster
  • How many Greeks speak Spanish
  • Apart from speaking and reading books how do I improve my speaking and writing skills in English Is there a website available where someone could correct me How long would it take to master these skills
  • Apart from speaking and reading books how do I improve my speaking and writing skills in English Is there a website available where someone could correct me How long would it take to master these skills
  • How many Filipinos can speak Spanish fluently nowadays
  • How do I say I speak a little Spanish in Spanish
  • If you speak only Spanish do you think in Spanish
  • Do Spanish speakers insert nonSpanish accents into their speech when enunciating nonSpanish names
  • Do Spanish speakers insert nonSpanish accents into their speech when enunciating nonSpanish names
  • Is it easier for a Spanish speaker to learn French or is it easier for a French speaker to learn Spanish
  • Do you like the Spanish language Why or why not
  • How different is Spain Spanish from say Mexican Spanish Puerto Rican Spanish Colombian Spanish etc Is CatalanCastilian that different from the Spanish we hear in the States
  • Besides Spain which country speaks the most standard Spanish
  • Do most nonnative Spanish speakers use proper grammar
  • How similar are Spanish and Italian languages
  • Is French grammar harder to learn than Spanish grammar and if so how
  • Is no problemo proper Spanish
  • How can I improve my English speaking reading and writing
  • Generally speaking how are profits split for a published book
  • Has the Great American novel already been written If you think so what is your choice and why
  • Generally speaking how are profits split for a published book
  • Has the Great American novel already been written If you think so what is your choice and why
  • How do I write the Great American Novel
  • If its been written what book is The Great American Novel
  • Are Aztec Nahuatl words used in Castilian Spanish
  • How many syllables exist in the American English language
  • Are Spanish people white
  • I have learnt the world hay in Spanish but whats the difference between haba and hubo
  • Is grammar important while you speak English
  • What would be the common Romance language between Romanian Portuguese Italian French and Spanish speakers
  • How do native speakers truly feel when speaking with nonnative English speakers
  • Generally speaking how are profits split for a published book
  • How well would I do in the AP Spanish language and culture exam if I am a native speaker of Spanish
  • Do Spanish people understand Mexican Spanish
  • Do Spanish people understand Mexican Spanish
  • How different is Mexican Spanish from Standard Castilian Spanish
  • Which book written in the last hundred years best qualifies as the Great American Novel
  • How is standard Mexican Spanish different from standard Colombian Spanish
  • Do native speakers make some grammar mistakes when they speak English
  • What are common mistakes native French speakers make when they speak English
  • Who prefer Russian as their native language and how many of them cannot speak fluent Ukrainian
  • What is the real difference between street Spanish and proper Spanish
  • How different is Mexican Spanish from Standard Castilian Spanish
  • How can I learn spanish
  • How can I say I will go there in Spanish
  • How do I say can I keep it when Im done in Spanish
  • How do I say I had to remember in Spanish
  • How do I say ignore in Spanish
  • How do I say look out the window in Spanish
  • How do I say yeah right in Spanish
  • How do you say AIDS in Spanish
  • How do you say Also in Spanish
  • How do you say As soon as possible in Spanish
  • How do you say drunk in Spanish
  • How do you say enjoy in Spanish
  • How do you say hard in Spanish
  • How do you say hi in Spanish
  • How do you say I am looking forward to in Spanish
  • How do you say How do you say something in Spanish
  • How do you say Im looking forward to something in Spanish
  • How do you say Im so glad in Spanish
  • How do you say loud in Spanish
  • How do you say maybe in Spanish
  • How do you say oops in Spanish
  • How do you say popcorn in Spanish
  • How do you say relaxation in Spanish
  • How do you say What do you recommend in Spanish
  • How do you say witch in Spanish
  • How formal is hay que in spanish
  • How hard could Spanish be
  • Im Spanish Can I say Im Latin
  • In Spanish how do you say lunch
  • Are Aztec Nahuatl words used in Castilian Spanish
  • Are Latinos considered Spanish
  • Are Spanish Mexican Hispanic the same thing
  • Are Spanish people white
  • Can I learn Spanish without a teacher
  • Can these Spanish phrases be considered idioms
  • Do most nonnative Spanish speakers use proper grammar
  • Are Latinos considered Spanish
  • Are Spanish Mexican Hispanic the same thing
  • Besides Spain which country speaks the most standard Spanish
  • Can I learn Spanish without a teacher
  • Can one learn Spanish from Duolingo
  • Can these Spanish phrases be considered idioms